Wyomingites dig new antler regs - they're even shed hunting because of them

At the behest of state lawmakers, Wyoming in 2024 took unprecedented steps to regulate shed antler hunting - actions that have started a western trend. Specifically, the Equality State now requires out-of-state residents to get a conservation stamp and to wait a week, giving residents a head start. 

Those changes caught some shed-seeking Westerners off-guard. But the majority of antler seekers are relishing the new rules, wildlife officials now know. 

"High levels of approval, in and of itself, shows that people were really receptive to the regulation," said University of California-Berkeley PhD candidate Sam Maher, who's been studying antler hunting in Wyoming since 2023. 

In 2024, Maher and her collaborators surveyed 318 shed hunters online and in person at trailheads within the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem, where there's a seasonal closure on antler gathering until May 1. The results suggest that 64% of all respondents were in favor of the new restrictions on non-resident antler gathering. To no surprise, Wyoming residents who stood to benefit were the most on board: 87% favored the new rules, versus just 27% of non-residents. 

The new regulations also motivated more locals to hit the hills. Some 22% of the Wyoming residents that Maher and company surveyed said they "would not have shed hunted otherwise," but went out because there was the perception of less competition. Non-residents, meanwhile, were effectively dissuaded from coming to Wyoming, even after they could on May 8. Some 29% of those surveyed reported not coming because of the new regulations. 

"We asked residents and non-residents how it changed their behavior," Maher said of the new rules. "It seemed like the increased enthusiasm by residents offset the fact that non-residents couldn't come in for the first week."

Studying under UC-Berkeley professor and seasonal Wyoming resident Arthur Middleton, Maher has been examining the burgeoning pursuit of antlers in the American West for a chapter in her dissertation. The first batch of data she received after her 2023 surveys provided new insights into the demographic makeup of shed hunters: The majority are white male westerners who like nature and exercise and are not motivated by the high dollar that elkhorn can fetch. She's adapted the results into a user-friendly story map dubbed "Brown Gold Rush."    

There's also a greater goal for the research. Maher and the University of Wyoming's Tyler Kjorstad are working on an academic paper, "The emerging need to manage scavenged wildlife resources," that's going through the peer-review process with the Journal of Biological Conservation.

Kjorstad, who's with UW's College of Business, is also working with Maher on another paper estimating the economic contribution of shed hunting in Wyoming. All the data they're amassing, he said, is useful outside of academia. 

"There's information that's advantageous for policy managers and ecologists, and in my opinion, economists," Kjorstad told WyoFile.

The steps that Wyoming has taken to regulate shed antler hunting are "a big deal," Maher said. Those regulations started with seasonal closures back in 2009 to protect wintering wildlife, but have since evolved to protect the experience of shed antler hunting. Antlers fall into a "weird gray area" because, after they separate from an animal, they're typically not protected from commercial sale, like wild game meat is. 

"The act of regulating this is pretty unprecedented and interesting," Maher said. It sets the stage, she said, for land and wildlife managers to regulate "similar resources," naming bird feathers, snake skins and seashells. 

Already, neighboring states are copying Wyoming's approach to regulating shed hunting. Starting in 2025, for example, out-of-state shed hunters in Idaho will have to possess a nonresident hunting license - a $185 investment. The Montana Legislature also is weighing a bill that proposes a $50 non-resident license fee for shed hunting, according to the Montana Free Press' bill tracker.

WyoFile is an independent nonprofit news organization focused on Wyoming people, places and policy.